Peer Review Guidelines
The journal operates under a double-anonymized peer-review model (see NISO Peer Review Terminology). Reviewers play a vital role in maintaining the academic quality, rigor, and international relevance of the journal.
Peer Review Model (NISO Standard Terminology)
Identity transparency: double anonymized (author and reviewer identities are not disclosed to each other and are known only to the handling editor).
Reviewer interacts with: editor (all communication is mediated through the editor via the OJS system; there is no direct interaction between reviewers or between reviewers and authors).
Review information published: none (peer review reports are securely stored in OJS, with access restricted to the handling editor; reports and reviewer identities are not published alongside the article).
Post-publication discussion: letters to the editor (see Publication Ethics).
The journal applies external peer review.
Reviewers must not attempt to identify authors in a double-anonymized process. If a reviewer recognizes the authors, identifies an institutional link, or if anonymity is otherwise compromised at any stage, the reviewer must inform the editor and withdraw from the review.
Who are our reviewers?
Members of the academic community with advanced expertise in relevant fields.
Independent external experts, both domestic and international.
Typically hold a doctoral degree and have a proven research track record.
Actively engaged in research, with publications in the same or related fields.
In exceptional cases, an Editorial Board member may serve as one of the two required reviewers, subject to the conditions set out in the Peer Review Policy.
Before Accepting a Review Invitation
Before agreeing to review a manuscript, please consider:
Expertise: Is the subject within your academic competence?
Availability: Can you complete the review within 4–6 weeks?
Conflicts of Interest: Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest (e.g., recent collaboration, same department/institution, financial or personal relationships). If a conflict exists, reviewers should decline the invitation. If a conflict becomes apparent after accepting, reviewers must inform the editor and withdraw from the review.
Timely Response: Please respond promptly to review invitation.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Maintain strict confidentiality of all manuscripts.
Do not involve anyone else (e.g., colleagues or junior researchers/students) in the review or share manuscript/review materials without the editor’s prior permission. If permission is granted, inform the editor of all individuals involved and maintain full confidentiality.
Ensure objectivity and impartiality in their evaluation, focusing solely on scholarly merit and relevance to the journal’s scope.
Apply critical thinking and constructiveness, offering reasoned arguments and specific suggestions for improvement.
Communicate at a high professional standard, avoiding personal remarks or inappropriate language.
Reviewers must not contact authors directly; all communication must be mediated through the editor via OJS.
Report any ethical concerns (plagiarism, duplicate publication, data falsification) confidentially to the Editorial Office:
Subject: Ethical Concern – [Manuscript ID]